Why Am I So Afraid of What I Feel?

Most of us know the moment. Someone walks into the room and you can tell they're not happy. A text comes back a little short. A family member says something with that tone. And before you've decided anything, something in you has already shifted. You get quieter, more agreeable and you start scanning. Are they upset? Is it me? What do I need to do? Or you go the other way. You get sharp, defensive, ready to push back. Either way, something has taken over. And later, when everything has calmed down, you think back on it and go, Yeah. That wasn't so good.

In moments like these, it seems obvious what we're afraid of: the person, the conflict, the situation. But over years of doing trauma therapy, I've come to believe something different. What we fear most often isn't the event itself. It's what the event makes us feel.

The trigger stirs up an emotion, such as anger, sadness, shame, or helplessness, and something in us has learned that feelings are dangerous. So before we even know what's happening, we're pleasing, defending, withdrawing, or controlling. We aren't really handling the other person. We're trying not to feel what's rising up inside us.

Our deepest fear may be the feeling itself.

Where the Fear of Feeling Comes From

So where does this fear of emotion come from?

Little children don't seem afraid of their emotions. They feel something, and they express it. The tears, the tantrum, the whole thing, right there on the kitchen floor.

But somewhere along the way, many of us learned that emotions weren't welcome. Perhaps the adults around us couldn't handle them and responded with sharp disapproval. Maybe happy feelings were acceptable and painful ones weren't. Or maybe the feelings themselves were simply too big for a young nervous system to manage. Either way, our systems learned to keep feelings away, and in some cases to become afraid of feeling them at all.

Trauma deepens this. It can disconnect us from the present moment, from our bodies, and from our emotions. We may go numb, shut down, or drift away from ourselves.

Each of us develops our own way of keeping feelings at bay. Some learn to keep everybody else happy. Some learn to manage and control. These strategies make sense. They're rooted in real experiences, painful ones, that the body still remembers even when the mind has moved on. But the feelings don't actually go away. They just come out sideways, in reactions we don't choose and later regret.

We can learn to stay with what we feel.

The answer isn't simply to express everything we feel. And it isn't to get better at suppressing it. There's another option.

We can learn to welcome feelings, and stay with what we feel.

That means allowing a feeling to be present without immediately making it disappear. Think of the emotions that tend to show up when you're triggered: frustration, fear, sadness, helplessness, guilt, shame. Pick one you recognize. Notice the impulse to push it away. Notice where you feel it in your body. Then see if you can become curious about it, maybe even welcome it, and stay present without needing to escape.

This is very different from being overwhelmed by emotion. The goal isn't to drown in the feeling.

The goal is to discover that I can feel this and still be here.

What the Work Actually Looks Like

In therapy, much of the work involves moving back and forth between three tasks.

First, we practice staying present with what we feel. We return to the feeling, a little at a time, and discover that we can experience it without suppressing it or disconnecting from it. This is what it means to widen your window of tolerance. Over time, we can experience stronger emotions without becoming overwhelmed, shutting down, or losing ourselves. The goal isn't to stop having difficult feelings. It's to become grounded enough that I don't lose myself when they come.

Second, we resource. I think of resourcing as learning a new language. The old language may be fear, pleasing, submission, and compliance. Or it may be anger, defensiveness, and control. The new language sounds more like calm, clarity, curiosity, compassion, confidence, and courage. For me, it's also the language of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, and gentleness. Like any language, we learn it by practicing it, not simply by understanding it.

Third, we reprocess. We explore the experiences that first taught our system to fear these feelings. Where did I learn that this feeling was dangerous? When did my system decide I needed to please, shut down, perform, control, or disappear in order to be safe? This is where approaches like EMDR are especially helpful. We aren't just managing today's trigger. We're healing what gives the trigger its power.

Perfect Love Drives Out Fear

For me, faith sits right at the center of all this. Scripture says that perfect love drives out fear. I don't read that as a command to try harder not to be afraid. I read it as a description of what begins to happen as love becomes real to us. It stops being something we only understand in our heads and becomes something we experience more and more deeply.

I am safe. I am loved. I am secure. I am united with Christ. And from that place, I can feel this. I don't have to make the feeling disappear. And I don't have to disappear.

Where to Start

If any of this sounds familiar, here's a simple place to begin. At the end of each day, take a few minutes and ask yourself: Did I get triggered today? If you did, don't immediately analyze it or try to fix it. Just get curious. What happened? What did you notice in your body? What did you want to do: please, defend, withdraw, control, shut down?

Then ask one more question: What was I afraid I was going to feel?

You don't have to do anything with the answer yet. Just notice. Perhaps the goal isn't to stop feeling anxious, sad, angry, powerless, or ashamed. Perhaps the deeper work is discovering that you can feel those things without leaving yourself. I can notice what is happening. I can stay with what I feel. I can remember who I am.

And over time, I can begin to heal what taught me to be so afraid of my own feelings.

Previous
Previous

Faith Integrated Counseling for Adults in Florida: Is It Right for You?

Next
Next

Online EMDR Therapy in Georgia, Virginia & North Carolina: How Virtual Trauma Work Actually Works